Jeremy Beecher, the close ally and anointed successor of ousted editor Zach Fox, “overwhelmingly” won the second election for Daily Trojan editor-in-chief Friday.
Fox, who won the first election but was prevented from taking office by USC Vice President of Student Affairs Michael Jackson, decided last night to throw his support to Beecher in the second election. He was apparently successful in nixing a write-in campaign on his behalf and consolidating support behind Beecher.
Fox will serve under Beecher in a lesser capacity — precisely what capacity is not clear — and they will continue to pursue the reforms that Fox had promised, which so irked the administration that they refused to recognize Fox’s initial election. (Facing intense pressure and bad press, the administration eventually pledged to respect the results of today’s election even if Fox had won as a write-in candidate, but Fox reportedly decided that his long-term goals would be better served by remaining more behind-the-scenes while his ally Beecher assumes the reigns. Fox told the Harvard Crimson yesterday: “I feel like it might be beneficial, not to stop fighting this, but if someone else were to fight it so that the administration would realize that this is a demand for transparency that hopefully won’t go away.”)
Zachary Franklin, who lost to Fox in the first election and sided with Dr. Jackson in the ensuing conflict, reportedly self-destructed as he “completely went off in his speech,” drawing gasps as he accused Fox and Beecher of playing martyrs in pursuit of “personal glory.” Franklin “really killed his chances with his own speech,” according to my source.
I don’t have the exact vote tally, and don’t know whether it will be forthcoming. [UPDATE: Reportedly, there were 36 votes for Beecher, 4 for Franklin, and 2 write-ins for Fox.]
So ends, somewhat anticlimactically, this stage of the Zach Fox controversy. As I wrote previously:
Electing Beecher rather than Fox (and putting Fox in a more behind-the-scenes capacity) strikes me as a “lose the battle, win the warâ€? strategy. Obviously, it would be a cathartic moral victory to elect Fox a second time, forcing the administration to accept the very candidate it initially rejected. But, according to one of my sources on staff, “editorial and financial independence are the eventual goals” — and, according to another source, the fear is that it will be more difficult to achieve those goals with Fox as the newspaper’s public face, given how many administrators he has already angered. Beecher is, I gather, viewed as more diplomatic, or at least as having less baggage simply because he’s not Zach Fox. …
The good news is, although a decision by the staff to elect someone other than Fox might seem like a victory for the administration, it’s a hollow one. Not only would a Beecher/Fox administration at the DT continue to push for much-needed reforms that the administration would rather not see happen, but the mere fact that Jackson has been forced to furiously backpedal and publicly pledge to accept a second Fox victory is itself a major victory for Daily Trojan independence. After seeing how this played out, methinks the administration will be very hesitant to make a move like this one again. By overplaying his hand, Jackson has weakened his (and the Media Board’s) position, long-term.
It’ll be interesting to see how things play out next semester, and I hope my new contacts at the Daily Trojan will keep me informed. :)
UPDATE: A little bit behind the times, but I just noticed this post on L.A. Observed which contains a video report from yesterday’s forum with Dr. Jackson:
The money quote comes from Jackson, who waffles on whether he “regrets” rejecting Fox’s application, but then says: “Maybe if I faced the same situation in the future, I might do it a little bit differently.” This is precisely what I was talking about above. Whether he wants to directly admit it or not, Jackson has obviously been chastened by this experience, which is a victory for the editors in their power struggle with the administration. And what’s great is, from Jackson’s persective, this setback was entirely self-inflicted. Thanks to his general ham-handedness, the administration came off looking arbitrary, arrogant and censorious. Personal foul, 15-yard penalty, first down student editors.
That said, the interview with Jackson also brings to mind an important hurdle that will be the next major “event” in this story: the Media Board will meet on Monday to consider editor-elect Beecher’s application. What will they do? I’d bet the house they approve him with nary a peep of protest, in light of all the bad press of the past week. But we won’t know for sure until Monday.
UPDATE 2: Michael Jackson just sent out an e-mail in response to the letter from 15 ex-editors that lambasted his decision and called his initial refusal to explain it on-the-record “perhaps arrogance, perhaps cowardice, but…certainly not leadership.” His response?
Dear Blake [Hennon]:
Thanks very much for your thoughtful email. We will keep these thoughts in mind as we work with students to make sure the DT continues to be an excellent student newspaper and educational, training, and leadership development program for students.
I hope all else is well.
Sincerely,
Michael Jackson
|
Categories: Daily Trojan: Zach Fox controversy
|
December 1st, 2006 at 4:59:19 pm
A victory, it seems, but there’s more going on here. I hope Fox and Beecher get their hands on the budget numbers and figure out what’s what.
I can’t believe Zachary Franklin blew up in his speech like that. I bet it’ll lead to some awkward silences if he stays on staff.
Thanks for blogging this and keeping all us alums in the loop.
-Dan
December 1st, 2006 at 6:15:27 pm
I heard the vote was 36-4. I can say from experience with both that the better man won — quite easily, which is a relief.
December 1st, 2006 at 6:49:41 pm
Michael Jackson is such a tool. I remember when the students against sweatshop people had that sit-in in Sample’s office and he was threatening to take away their scholarships and to kick them out of school and all this other shit. He’s the biggest jackass ever.
December 1st, 2006 at 8:17:05 pm
Aww give the guy a break Becky, think of all the legal trouble he’s been through, not to mention changing race AND gender. It must be hard to deal with college students when we all know he wishes he was dealing with middle school kids…oh…wait…wrong Michael Jackson ;-)
December 1st, 2006 at 10:04:54 pm
Aww, David, you’re such a card! You crack me up, buddy! Comedic gold!
December 2nd, 2006 at 12:34:53 am
Go for it, Fox and Beecher! Those cries from the bleachers you hear are not from USC alum but from UCLA Daily Bruin editors, who shall be nameless except for me, who in decades…yes, that’s decades…past have had to deal with the admin’s fools who can’t sleep nights because the campus paper commits the terrorist act of nominating and electing its own editors. The second biggest nightmare for college bureaucrats, aside from losing $$$ from donors, is that the newspaper will have an independent voice. Wonder if there’s a connection there.
If you stick to your guns, I promise you’ll remember it 50 years from now.
Clancy Sigal, former managing editor, Daily Bruin
December 2nd, 2006 at 7:44:43 pm
I didn’t realise that “Cardinal” was one of the official USC colours … yet, somehow, Eminence Bordelaise sounds a little too easy to make fun of, as descriptive of the Power behind the Trojan Throne, so to speak …
December 3rd, 2006 at 1:29:42 am
I am glad to see the DT staffers prudently followed my advice.
December 9th, 2006 at 9:00:23 pm
Words cannot even begin to describe how badly Franklin went off on Fox and on Beecher as well. Interesting strategy to go after and rip into a guy who had received a standing ovation at the all-staff dinner just the night before. Fox storming out of the room during the speech because of Franklin’s twisting of Fox’s words and intentions led to the most drama an all-staff DT meeting has seen in years!